Much like the belt of the machine itself, certain treadmill questions seem to roll around again and again. Here are some answers.
Q: Just how accurate are those "calories burned" numbers?
Short answer: Not terribly.
Longer answer: Treadmills fool us by estimating total calories burned during our time on the machine rather than the net number—i.e., calories burned solely through exercise, above and beyond what we would have used anyway. (We all burn a certain number of calories even at rest.)
Here are some simple equations to calculate and compare total calories burned per mile versus net:
For running (5 mph and higher): Total calories burned per mile = .75 x body weight (in pounds); net calories burned per mile = .63 x weight.
For walking (3 to 4 mph): Total calories burned per mile = .53 x body weight; net calories burned per mile = .30 x weight.
Which workout really burns more fat? Read Running vs. Walking for Weight Loss to find out.
Q: Is treadmill running easier than running at the same speed outdoors?
Short answer: Yes.
Longer answer: Treadmill running may feel more taxing, but physiologically it's actually a bit easier than running outdoors.
Q: Can I train on a treadmill for a road race?
Short answer: If you must.
Longer answer: You can train for a road race mostly on a treadmill, says Jenny Hadfield, coauthor of Running for Mortals and Marathoning for Mortals and a runnersworld.com columnist. But you'll have to make a few tweaks. For starters, be sure to increase the incline and run "hills" on the treadmill once or twice a week. And because treadmill belts offer a relatively soft landing, take steps to prepare your body for racing on asphalt:
- Strength-train twice a week (lunges, squats, hip extensions, planks, push-ups).
- Do at least one short outdoor run each week during the last four weeks of training.
- During your race, walk a minute at every mile marker or aid station. This will ease the overall impact on your body and give you a chance to hydrate.
- Finally, on race day, run by effort--not by pace or time goals. You'll be on unfamiliar ground, literally. (No matter where your next competition is, avoid these Most Common Race-Day Disasters.)
Q: Are treadmills "easier" on your body than running outdoors?
Yes and no.
Longer answer: In general, running on a treadmill is less stressful on the body than running outdoors. John Post, the medical director for TrainingBible Coaching, explains that the treadmill absorbs a significant amount of impact, sparing your body. On the other hand, he says, "The downside is that it doesn't condition the shock-absorbing musculature of the lower extremities like road running does."
Result: Over the long term, heavy treadmill use may actually leave you more prone to injuries like stress fractures.