Running Injury Diagnosis: 6 Signs You Need a Second Opinion

John Mayer had been an avid runner since high school. But at age 45, in 2005, a pain in his knee was getting worse, so he went to see a physician. "This fellow came highly recommended," says Mayer, of Chicago. After diagnosing a torn anterior cruciate ligament, "he told me there was nothing to do. He was so respected, so convincing, and so definitive that I didn't even bother to get a second opinion."

Mayer was crushed and didn't lace up for six months. When he tried to run again, the pain came back. Finally a friend suggested he see another doctor, who confirmed the problem but recommended arthroscopic surgery and physical therapy. Mayer's pain eased, and he's since run eight marathons.

Not every treatment plan requires a second opinion. But when you're undergoing rehab—and anxious to run again—it's important to know when to seek a different perspective.

More: 3 Ways to Prevent Running Injuries

You're told that there's nothing to be done.

Almost all running injuries are treatable. So if a doctor tells you he can do nothing for you, make an appointment with another expert. That diagnosis most likely means "there's nothing more that that doctor can offer," says Michael Ross, M.D., medical director of The Rothman Institute Performance Lab in Cherry Hill, New Jersey. And while some conditions, such as severe arthritis in the hip, ankle, or knee, could certainly curtail your career, you'll want to confirm a diagnosis like that with another physician before you quit running altogether. (Don't let injury keep you from running again—learn how to cope with the Stages of Injury Recovery.)

More: 4 Ways to Stay Positive Through Injuries

You've developed a new pain.

Sue Walsh was a month from the Chicago Marathon in 2008 when she developed an IT-band injury and visited a physical therapist. "The IT band got better, but my hip flexor on that same side started to hurt," says Walsh, 33, from Brooklyn. "I couldn't get it together for the marathon."

An appropriate treatment plan should not cause new aches. "A patient who is experiencing increased pain or pain in new locations is likely getting therapy that is overly aggressive for their condition, or was misdiagnosed and should be reassessed," says Michael Chin, D.P.M., medical director of The Running Institute in Chicago. (If conventional methods aren't working, try these 5 Natural Solutions to Pain Relief.)

Another doctor later diagnosed Walsh with femoroacetabular impingement, a bone deformity of the hip that required surgery. She finally got back to running two years after the initial IT-band issue.

More: 5 Stretches to Keep You Injury Free

You notice no improvements after two to four weeks.

Most injuries should improve and pain should diminish after four to six sessions of therapy, Dr. Chin says. If they don't, the rehab plan may be too conservative. David Bakke, 45, of Atlanta, was diagnosed with runner's knee a week after he started bounding up the steps of the local football stadium. He was told to do some stretching exercises and rest for seven to 10 days. After two weeks, when he'd noticed no improvements, Bakke went to see another doctor who prescribed exercises to strengthen his quadriceps. "In about 10 days, I was finally able to resume my full workout," says Bakke.

More: The Aches and Pains of Newbie Running

  • 1
  • of
  • 2

Discuss This Article