"Macca" is a naturally big fellow. A more typical example of off-season weight gain at the elite level is that of Ryan Hall. The half marathon American record-holder gains three to five pounds after each marathon as a result of training less and allowing himself to eat a little less carefully than he normally does. Hall considers this weight gain a good thing—part of his body’s overall recovery from the stress of the recently completed training cycle. He looks at a three- to five-pound weight increase as an indication that his body is ready to return to structured training.
If you really wanted to, you could minimize post-race weight gain by reducing your food intake by an amount that’s commensurate to your reduction in training. But it would be difficult to pull off because it takes a while for appetite to decrease after a drop in training volume.
More: Your Guide to a Healthy Offseason
I think it's OK to eat enough to satisfy your appetite in the off-season, even if it means you gain a few pounds. In fact, I see nothing wrong with allowing yourself, for at least the first couple of weeks after a big race, to indulge in a few more treats than you normally eat when you’re trying to get fit and lean for a big race. Again, this is something that most elite athletes do.
Reward the disciplined eating you do within the training cycle by having a little ice cream between cycles. This will actually make it easier to return to disciplined eating at the start of the next one, much as a break from training restores the hunger to train.
It is possible, of course, to let off-season weight gain get out of hand. The best way to avoid this is to take another cue from the elites and set a personal weight-gain limit. Chris McCormack doesn’t let his weight creep above 185. Ryan Hall limits his post-marathon weight gain to three to five pounds. Determine a limit that’s appropriate for you and respect it—but also use it!
More: 5 Ways to Avoid Unwanted Offseason Weight
Sign up for your next race.